I bought the jars at Hobby Lobby (if you catch them on sale, you can get a great deal!). They have a ton of different sizes and styles. I decided to etch their names on the jars (see the tutorial here), and fill them with things in their favorite colors.
My main gifts to them were the bracelets I made (see the tutorials here and here),
but I also gave each of them a pair of the earrings that I refashioned (see post here),
and bought fuzzy footies, gloves, nail polish, emery boards, and lip balm. They're also getting those cute notebooks & pens from Pick Your Plum (see post here).
After I filled the jars, I tied a ribbon around the lid and attached one of the Apple Cinnamon Orange Clove ornaments that I made (see tutorial here).
I hope they like them!!